In trade wars of 200 years ago, the pirates were Americans


In trade wars of 200 years ago, the pirates were Americans

  • By PAUL WISEMAN AP Economics Writer

WASHINGTON (AP) — The upstart nation was a den of intellectual piracy. One of its top officials urged his countrymen to steal and copy foreign machinery. Across the ocean, a leading industrial power tried in vain to guard its trade secrets from the brash young rival.

In the late 18th and early 19th centuries, the rogue nation was the United States. The official endorsing thievery was Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton. And the main victim was Britain.

How times have changed.

Now, the United States accuses China of the very sort of illicit practices that helped America leapfrog European rivals two centuries ago and emerge as an industrial giant.

"The message we are sending to China today is, Do as I say, not as I did,' " said Peter Andreas, professor at Brown University's Watson Institute for International and Public Affairs. "The fact of the matter is that the U.S. was the world's hotbed of intellectual property theft."

Offering serious and challenging mathematics to intellectually gifted students

Having imposed tariffs on $250 billion in Chinese goods, the Trump administration is trying to force Beijing to abandon what it calls its brass-knuckles drive to exploit American technology to speed its own economic modernization. The administration alleges — and many China watchers agree — that Beijing steals trade secrets and coerces U.S. companies to hand them over as the price of admission to the vast Chinese market.

More than two centuries ago, the young United States, an agrarian backwater lacking in skilled workers, held a different view of other nations' trade secrets: They were, it seemed, up for grabs. In 2012, having surveyed the sordid history of U.S. industrial espionage, the journal Foreign Policy called America "the China of the 19th century.

"Only after becoming the leading industrial power did it become a champion of intellectual-property protections," said Andreas, author of "Smuggler Nation: How Illicit Trade Made America."

Hamilton, determined to transform America into an industrial power, argued in 1791 that the United States needed "to procure all such machines as are known in any part of Europe."

Trouble was, Britain, the world's technological leader, closely guarded its advantages. The London government imposed a 200-pound fine (equal to roughly $22,000 today) on anyone who tried to spirit industrial equipment out of Britain — a penalty that escalated to 500 pounds ($55,000) for critically important textile machines, according to research by Doron Ben-Atar, a Fordham University historian and the author of "Trade Secrets: Intellectual Piracy and the Origins of American Industrial Power."

Award-Winning After-School Math Program for K-12 Students

For the 18th century United States to build its economic might, highly skilled or knowledgeable people were just as tempting a target as hardware. In the days before instruction manuals, manufacturers needed workers who knew how to assemble and operate machines acquired from overseas. Wary of the intrusion, Britain officials threatened headhunters with a year in prison for every British worker they recruited to work overseas.

Yet they couldn't stop the brain drain, which the U.S. government actively encouraged. In 1791, Hamilton authorized the Treasury to pay $48 to subsidize the living expenses of an English weaver who pledged to deliver to the U.S. a copycat version of a British spinning machine.

One key defection was Samuel Slater of Derbyshire, who had apprenticed under a leading British industrialist. Figuring his prospects were brighter across the Atlantic, Slater disguised himself as a farmer, boarded a ship to the United States, signed on with a business owner in Rhode Island and replanted Britain's cutting-edge cotton-spinning technology on American soil. In the United States, he was sometimes called "the father of the American Industrial Revolution."

Back in Britain, he was accorded a rather different nickname: "Slater the Traitor."

APLUS教学中心 | 一对一辅导服务中心 | 申请咨询顾问中心

Perhaps the most impressive heist was orchestrated in the early 1800s by Francis Cabot Lowell, the Massachusetts industrialist. During a tour of England and Scotland, Lowell had visited British textile factories and managed to memorize their design and inner workings. On the voyage back to America, Lowell's ship was stopped and searched by British officials who had been tipped off that he might have stolen industrial designs. They found nothing; the secrets were all in Lowell's head. He would go on to establish a textile-producing empire in Massachusetts.

Intellectual pirates were celebrated in the young United States, just as they are now in China. A man who smuggled a cotton-processing machine from London was hailed by one Pennsylvania trade group as "the ingenious artizan who counterfeited the Carding and Spinning Machine" and was promised awards and prizes, according to Andreas' book. His copycat equipment was displayed on a float in Philadelphia's July 4 parade of 1788.

Likewise, today's Chinese industrial spies sometimes earn public recognition. The Justice Department asserts that a former Coca-Cola engineer who is accused of stealing trade secrets worth $100 million was partly scheming to win the Chinese "Thousand Talent" award, as well as an award from Shandong Province for people who transport valuable technology to China.

Douglas Irwin, a Dartmouth College economist who wrote a 2017 history of U.S. trade policy "Clashing Over Commerce," cautioned that the early American efforts to gain a technological edge were nowhere near as comprehensive as China's efforts are today. In an audacious blueprint called Made in China 2025, Beijing has designed a plan to create world-beating Chinese companies in such advanced fields as robotics and electric cars. In pursuing this goal, the U.S. charges, China has unfairly subsidized its own companies and hobbled foreign competitors.

By contrast, Congress wouldn't approve Hamilton's most ambitious plans for a U.S. industrial policy, Ben-Atar has noted. But the United States back then didn't really need much help from the government, he said. It enjoyed — and enjoys — an advantage that today's China doesn't: Foreigners want to live in America. And those who do bring their knowledge and talent.

China, ruled by an authoritarian Communist regime, isn't very inviting to foreigners who might otherwise put down roots.

"The best and brightest in the world still don't go to China," Ben-Atar said. "They go to the Silicon Valley and Route 128 in Boston and the Research Triangle in North Carolina. ... The jury's out on whether a society dedicated to repression can actually become the mecca of innovation."

Even so, Ben-Atar doubts that the U.S. can effectively keep its technology from slipping away.

"The history of trying to restrict the movement of technology is the history of failure," he said.

In the 13th century, he noted, the Italian city-state of Venice sought to protect its glass-making industry by isolating its artisans on the island of Murano. Venice's secrets got out anyway.

Andreas doesn't object to the U.S. trying to combat Chinese piracy. But "the finger-pointing and righteous indignation," he said, "should be tempered by a historical reality check."


Let all ginseng lovers get the real ginseng from Wisconsin




  美联社作家威斯曼(Paul Wiseman)28日发表文章表示,18及19世纪中最热衷窃取别国先进技术的,不是他国,正是美国;而美国现今指责中国大陆从事这种偷窃违法行为,曾在两世纪前帮助美国超越欧洲竞争对手,成为工业巨人。

  两百多年前,美国尚处于缺乏技术劳工的年轻国家,也一样无视别人要求保障商业机密,靠着偷窃技术来进步。杂志"外交政策"(Foreign Policy)2012年详查美国过去这段工业间谍的可耻历史后,称19世纪的美国活脱脱就是今日的中国。

  文章指出,鼓动剽窃的官员是当时的美国财长汉密尔顿(Alexander Hamilton),苦主则是英国。汉密尔顿为让国家转变为工业强权,1791年时主张美国需"取得一切在欧洲出名的机械"。美国在18世纪要想成为经济强权,获得高级技术人员或业内行家,也跟取得硬体一样重要。

  智财海盗当时还会获美国赞扬。现为美国布朗大学华森国际与公共事务研究中心(Brown University's Watson Institute for International and Public Affairs)、着有"走私者国度:非法贸易如何造就美国"(Smuggler Nation: How Illicit Trade Made America)一书的安德瑞亚斯(Peter Andreas)在其书中所载,一个将棉花处理机具从伦敦走私到美国的人,还被宾州贸易团体盛赞"山寨纺织机具的巧匠",愿提供重赏。这部仿冒版的机具,还出现在1788年于费城举行的国庆游行队伍。汉密尔顿1791年时还授权财政部,给愿将仿制版英国纺织机械带到美国的英国纺织工人生活津贴。



Tel: (301)906-6889; 
Licensed in MD, VA, DC, WV, PA, DE, NC, SC, FL 
WeChat ID: sunnychenyuqing
NMLS # 1220187

President, Principal Loan Consultant, Leader Funding, Inc.
Wechat ID: Willow6621
NMLS # 208136

电话: (240) 784-6645

Phone: 301-366-3497

Simon Lin